Toastie Recipes

The Best Toastie Fillings

by

Discovering perfect toastie fillings can transform your simple snack into a taste extravaganza. Drawing from my own extensive toastie experience (fuelling the recipe content of this website), I have identified a selection of the Best Toastie Fillings that consistently deliver exceptional flavour, satisfying texture and a great toasted sandwich.

Whether you prefer classic combinations or innovative twists, this simple list of the best toastie fillings aims to inspire your next toastie and elevate it from average to SUPERB.

A Quick Word on Cheese

Before I dive into the best toastie fillings, a quick word on cheese. A number of filling suggestions below will list cheese as an ingredient and a number won’t. However. this doesn’t mean you can’t add cheese to those options as well. As you know, every toastie can have a cheese option.

Best Toastie Fillings

Like the humble toastie, I like to keep things simple and to the point, so rather than waffle on about each filling idea in detail talking about the weather and my feelings or some such shit while I cooked it to try to claw up the Google rankings, I have simply made an easy to read list. It will probably be read by AI and presented to you but…at least you get a great list of the best toastie fillings.

  1. Strong Cheddar Cheese and Onion
  2. Baked Beans
  3. Fish Fingers
  4. Bacon and Brie
  5. Sausage and Onion Marmalade
  6. Cheese and Roasted Tomatos
  7. Cheese and Branston Pickle
  8. Pastrami and Gherkins (pickles in the USA)
  9. Chicken and Bacon (mayo sauce optional)
  10. Bacon, Lettuce and Tomato
  11. Bacon and BBQ Beans
  12. Fried eggs with Brown Sauce (runny yolk is essential)
  13. Tuna and Mozzarella Cheese
  14. Steak and Onions (ideally with them both cooked in a Soy and Honey Sauce)
  15. Ham and Cheddar Cheese
  16. Left over Bolognese
  17. Smashed Avocado with Smoky Bacon and chilli (the avocado should be seasoned with garlic and lime juice)
  18. Chicken in a Pesto Mayonnaise
  19. Black Pudding and Fried Eggs
  20. Egg Mayonnaise
  21. Chicken, Stuffing, Bread Sauce, and Sausages (also known as the leftover Sunday roast toastie)
  22. Roast Beef, Horseradish and Mozzarella Cheese (with a French Dip on the side)
  23. Meatballs with Marinara Sauce
  24. Brie, Branston Pickle and Thick Cut Crisps
  25. Cheddar Cheese, Mince Meat and Chips/Fries (think dirty fries in a toasted sandwich)
  26. Chip Shop Chips
  27. Chicken Tikka
  28. Gouda cheese and Tomato Chutney
  29. Peanut Butter and Banana
  30. Leftover Fajita Chicken and Peppers
  31. Banana and Strawberry Jam
  32. Banana and Nutella
  33. Sausage, Bacon and Eggs

Now You Have Seen the List – Give them a try

Hopefully, in that long list of great toastie fillings you have found at least one that you want to try.

So, give it a go and let me know how you got on.

Or, if there is anything you would add to this list of the best toastie fillings then also get in touch.

If you like toasties and want great toastie recipes delivered to you each week, then join the Toastie Club now. Plus, as a thank you for joining the community and to help you on your toastie journey, I will send you a small digital reciepe book with 30 great toastie ideas in it.

Happy eating.