30 Real Toasted Sandwich Recipes
Looking for original, tasty, and tested Toastie Ideas? You have come to the right place as I’ve pulled together 30 of my favourite tasty toastie recipe ideas for you.
Each one is very easy to make and will deliver a tasty toasted sandwich. How do I know this? Well – I’ve made them all. Yep, this is NOT a list of toastie recipes and pictures generated by AI but a real list of toasties that I’ve made and photographed.
If you want to try any of the toastie ideas shown then simply click on the title to go to the full recipe.
Also, if you would like all 30 complete recipes in one handy, free, digital recipe book then simply join the Toastie Club now and I will send you a copy direct to your inbox.
Baked bean and Cheese Toastie
One of my most popular recipes, and videos, this is a winning combination of baked beans and cheese. It makes a great choice on a cold rainy night, perfect comfort food.
Cheese and Pickle Toastie
Yep, this classic sandwich combination also makes a great toastie – The pickle provides a lovely zingy taste that goes wonderfully with the smooth cheese.
Pizza Toastie
Craving a midweek pizza? Why not have a Pizza Toastie instead to satisfy that craving.
Bolognese Toastie
This toastie is a great way to use up leftover bolognese.
Banana, Peanut Butter and Syrup Toastie
This delicious banana toastie is a great choice for a post workout meal. I’ve also enjoyed them after a run or hitting the weights.
Cheese, Mayo and Ketchup Toastie
So simple, so quick and so tasty.
Chilli, cheese and coriander toastie
A taste of tex mex in this fiery lunchtime toastie.
Cajun Spiced Baked Bean Quesadilla
Using your toastie maker with flat plates allows you to create great toastie wraps and quesadilla just like this one.
Cheese and Onion Toastie Wrap with Chili Jam
This tasty cheese and onion wrap is one of the most popular toasties on this site and for good reason.
Cheese, Tomato and Onion Toastie
The combination of spring onions and tomatoes give this toastie a lovely fresh taste.
Emmental Cheese and Mushroom Toastie
Earthy chestnut mushrooms and the nutty flavour of Emmental cheese combine brilliantly in this mushroom based toastie.
Egg, tomato and onion breakfast toastie
Start your day off right with this tasty egg based toastie.
Egg, Red Pepper and Cream Cheese Toastie
This ed pepper and cream cheese in this toastie is a great choice for a late afternoon snack with a cup of tea.
Fish fingers and baked bean toastie
Think of this fish finger toastie as dinner in a toastie.
Frankfurter Omelette Toasted Sandwich
Another great choice for breakfast of a post workout meal.
Gouda Cheese Toastie
When you create a pure cheese toastie one of the most important and fun aspects is getting great cheese pull and that is just what you will have with this Gouda cheese toastie.
Gouda and Salami Toastie
Taking a Gouda cheese toastie up a notch by adding a generous helping of salami.
Mushroom and Salami Toastie
Building once again on the toastie above this mushroom and salami toastie makes a great lunch.
Pesto, Tomato and Cheese Toasted Sandwich Recipe
Pesto with cheese and tomato is a real winning combination and they come together brilliantly in this toastie.
Pastrami, Mozzarella and Chutney Toasted Sandwich
Another delicious cured meat toastie to keep you full and smiling all afternoon.
Mushroom and Baked Bean Toastie
You may not have considered this combination before but I recommend you give it a try and you will never look back.
Naan Bread Toastie
Use up your leftover Indian takeaway in this toastie.
Sweet Chili Chicken Toasted Sandwich
This sweet and spicy toastie is a great way to use up leftover chicken.
Tuna Melt Toastie
A classic toasted sandwich recipe.
Garlic Mushroom Toastie
This garlic mushroom toastie is a great tasting lunch, but you may want to make sure all your meetings are online after enjoying this toastie.
Ham, Cheese and Mushroom Toastie Recipe
Three of my favourite ingredients come together is this classic toastie recipe.
Prosciutto and Gouda Toastie
The lovely salty prosciutto ham goes brilliantly with the soft smoky Gouda in this variation of a cheese and ham toastie.
Classic Grilled Cheese
A classic grilled cheese toastie made in a frying pan with lots of tasty butter. It is simple and delicious.
Soft bread roll toastie
Yep, you can make a toastie out of a soft bread roll and it is a great way to use up leftovers.
IKEA Meatball and Gravy Toastie
Turn those classic flavours from the worlds most famous furniture store into a delicious toastie.
Find the perfect toastie maker
If you haven’t found a toastie maker yet or are looking for an upgrade to your current model then be sure to check these onesout.
Toastie Club
If you have liked these recipes and don’t want to miss out on my next tasty toastie then sign up for the Toastie Club today. When you do you will also get an exclusive Toastie Club discount off my cooking guides and get a handy printable version of all the above recipes for free.
Affiliate Disclaimer
This list of 30 great toastie ideas contains affiliate links to Amazon UK. If you click on a link and make a purchase we may receive a small commission. This commission goes towards the running of Toastie Recipes. Thank you for your continued support.